Deciding on the right roof is a big move for homeowners in Pennsylvania. Whether you’re renovating an aging structure or building anew, selecting between an asphalt roof and metal roofing is pivotal. From pricing to longevity, curb appeal to energy efficiency, this guide unpacks it all with a fun, friendly tone—and a helpful nod to the roofing material comparison PA market.

1. Quick Overview: Why the Debate Matters in PA

Pennsylvania’s climate—from hot summers to wintry snowstorms—demands sturdy roofing. In this region:

• Asphalt roofs (shingles) have been the go-to for their affordability and ease of installation.
• Metal roofing has grown in popularity for superior durability and energy savings.

Let’s break down how each option performs in key areas critical to PA homeowners.

2. Material Costs: Upfront Investment vs. Longevity

Asphalt Roofing

• Average installed cost: $4 to $8 per square foot depending on shingle quality—ranging from basic three-tab to durable architectural styles.
• Total project cost: $6,000 to $9,800 for an average-size home.
• Lifespan: Typically, 15–30 years with premium shingles reaching up to 30 years.

Metal Roofing

• Installed cost: $8 to $14 per square foot, depending on materials like aluminum, steel, or copper.
• Total cost: $15,000 to $24,500 for a similar roof size.
• Entry-level steel panels run $8–$10/sq ft, while premium metal ranges up to $30/sq ft.
• Lifespan: Lasts 40–70 years—possibly a lifetime.

The Verdict: Asphalt is affordable now; metal pays off over time with longevity and fewer replacements.

3. Durability and Weather Resilience

Asphalt Shingles

Pros:

• Affordable,
• Available in many styles,
• Easier to install and repair.

Cons:

• Vulnerable to hail, wind, and rapid temperature shifts,
• Shorter lifespan,
• Potential for algae and rot in humid or shaded areas.

Metal Roofing

Strengths:

• Lasts 50+ years with minimal care,
• Superior wind, hail, fire, and snow resistance,
• Fireproof and eco-friendly (recyclable).

Drawbacks:

• Higher upfront cost,
• Noise during storms (mitigable with proper insulation),
• Slippery and requires professional care for maintenance.

4. Style & Aesthetic Options

Asphalt Roofing

• Offers variety in colors, textures, and dimensional designs.
• Architectural shingles mimic classic looks with shadow lines and layers.
• Blends with traditional Pennsylvania styles, from Colonial to modern farmhouse.

Metal Roofing

• Sleek modern look or classic appeal (shingles, standing seam).
• Available in bold palettes and reflective finishes.
• Popular for contemporary homes and historic renovations alike.

Choosing between bold or classic? Think of your home’s style—metal may offer more design energy, while asphalt brings familiarity.

5. Energy Efficiency & Eco-Friendliness

Asphalt Roofing

• Dark colors absorb heat—raising cooling costs in summer.
• Some reflective options exist, but less efficient than metal.

Metal Roofing

• Highly reflective—can lower cooling bills by up to 40% in summer; up to 15% savings in winter with proper installation.
• Made with recycled content, fully recyclable, and reduces landfill waste—unlike asphalt shingles that contribute significantly to debris streams.

Metal emerges as a greener, more cost-effective choice in long-term energy savings.

6. Roofing Material Comparison PA: Looking at Long-Term Value

• Asphalt: Low upfront cost, moderate lifespan, easy to source and repair.
• Metal: Higher investment, but lasts longer, offers long-term savings, and raises home value. Resale ROI is strong thanks to durability and modern appeal.

Think of it this way: pay once for metal and likely never rebuy a roof—versus multiple asphalt replacements over decades.

7. Installation & Maintenance Differences

Asphalt Shingles

• Quicker, easier install—ideal for tight timelines.
• Repairs are straightforward and often DIY-friendly.
• Requires replacement every few decades and periodic upkeep.

Metal Roofing

• More complex installation—needs skilled roofing contractors with precision for seams and flashing.
• The initial cost is offset by minimal maintenance demands.
• Great for homeowners looking for set-it-and-forget-it reliability.

8. Considerations Specific to Pennsylvania

• Heavy snow and ice: Metal sheds buildup easily, reducing ice dam risks.
• Wind: Metal roofs resist uplift better; architectural shingles offer better performance than three-tab options.
• Historic districts: Asphalt shingles may offer better aesthetic compatibility.
• Energy usage: Metal’s reflective properties help lower cooling costs during PA’s warm, humid summers.

9. Which Roof Should You Choose?

Here’s a quick decision table:

Pawning Off Roof Myths (and Real Talk)

“Metal roofs are louder, but with proper insulation I barely notice it.”
“Yes, metal costs double, but my neighbor’s roof needed total replacement three times in the same span.”
These snippets reflect real homeowner conversations—metal can solve recurring headaches, especially in places like Pennsylvania where harsh winters and storms are common.

10. When to Call the Local Pros

If you’re seeking help navigating between asphalt and metal, Lehigh Gap Exteriors specializes in roofing solutions tailored to our region:

• Expert cost breakdowns for roofing material comparison PA
• Quality installations by trusted roofing contractors Lehigh Valley
• Energy-efficient recommendations and style guidance
• Free estimates and warranty-informed decisions

11. Summary Quiz—Which Roof Fits You?

• On a budget, need fast service? -> Go Asphalt
• Want low-maintenance longevity and energy savings? -> Choose Metal
• Love classic looks for a traditional home? -> Stick with Asphalt
• Updating modern, high-value or eco-friendly home? -> Consider Metal

12. The Hidden Costs of Roofing: What Homeowners Overlook

When comparing roofing materials, homeowners often focus on sticker prices—but hidden costs over time can shift the balance. For asphalt, ongoing maintenance, occasional shingle replacements after storms, and full roof replacements every 20–25 years can add up significantly. With labor and materials becoming more expensive every year, that second or third replacement may cost far more than your first. On the other hand, a metal roof’s higher upfront cost can be offset by avoiding repairs, replacements, and even lower insurance premiums over the decades. In fact, many insurance providers offer discounts for metal roofing due to its fire resistance and storm durability—something worth checking with your agent.

13. What About Noise? Debunking a Common Metal Roof Myth

One of the biggest myths about metal roofs is that they’re extremely loud during rain or hailstorms. While this might be true for a bare-metal shed or barn, residential metal roofs are installed over solid decking with insulation layers that absorb sound. Modern standing seam metal systems, in particular, are engineered to reduce noise levels significantly. Many homeowners report little to no difference in sound compared to asphalt shingles once the metal roof is properly installed. So if you’re concerned about a “tin can” effect, rest assured—it’s mostly myth, especially when working with an experienced installer.

14. Curb Appeal and Resale Value: What’s More Attractive to Buyers?

If you’re planning to sell your home in the next 5–10 years, your roofing choice can directly affect your resale value and buyer interest. Metal roofing, with its sleek appearance and promise of durability, is often viewed as a premium upgrade. Buyers appreciate knowing they won’t need to budget for a roof replacement anytime soon. Asphalt still has wide appeal, especially for traditional-style homes, but it typically won’t add as much resale value unless it’s brand new. According to industry estimates, a metal roof can recoup up to 85% of its cost in resale value, while asphalt generally recoups about 60–70%. That’s a significant difference when considering ROI for your home improvement projects.

15. Matching Your Roof to Your Home’s Architecture

The architectural style of your home should influence your roofing choice. For example, Craftsman bungalows, Tudors, and traditional colonials often look best with dimensional asphalt shingles that mimic cedar shakes or slate. Metal roofs, however, shine on modern farmhouses, cabins, cottages, and contemporary homes—especially with standing seam or corrugated panels in bold hues like charcoal or matte black. You can also find metal shingles designed to replicate tile, slate, or wood shake—offering the best of both worlds: classic style with metal durability. Working with a roofing contractor who understands your home’s design is key to choosing the right material that complements—not clashes with—your curb appeal.

Ready to decide?

Reach out to Lehigh Gap Exteriors for a personalized consultation. We’ll help you compare options, review pricing, and ensure your roof choice fits your home—and your life—for years to come.